East Side Lutheran Church of Sioux Falls v. Next, Inc.

In 2002, East Side Lutheran Church contracted with NEXT, Inc. for construction of a new addition to its church and renovation to its existing structure. After the project was completed in 2003, East Side experienced a variety of problems throughout the structure. East Side filed suit against NEXT in July 2010. Defendants moved for summary judgment on the basis that East Side filed suit outside of the applicable six-year statute of limitations. The circuit court granted summary judgment to Defendants on the statute of limitations issue and on the issue of equitable estoppel. On appeal, the parties agreed that any claims that accrued before July 2004 were barred. At issue before the Supreme Court was whether there were any genuine issues of material fact as to whether any or all of East Side’s claims accrued before July 2004. The Supreme Court (1) reversed the circuit court’s ruling that barred East Side’s claims of design error and construction error, holding that a genuine issue of material fact existed to determine when those claims accrued; and (2) affirmed the circuit court’s grant of summary judgment on the equitable estoppel claim. Remanded. View "East Side Lutheran Church of Sioux Falls v. Next, Inc. " on Justia Law